Enhancement-led Institutional Review (ELIR) is QAA's review method for universities and other higher education institutions in Scotland.
The main focus of ELIR is to consider an institution's strategic approach to enhancement, placing a particular emphasis on the arrangements for improving the student learning experience. ELIR also examines the institution's ability to secure the academic standards of its awards.
It is one component of the Quality Enhancement Framework (QEF), a radical approach to quality assurance and enhancement in higher education introduced in Scotland in 2003.
How it works
ELIR reviews are carried out by a team of six reviewers: one student reviewer, one international reviewer, three senior UK-based academic reviewers and one coordinating reviewer.
The institution undergoing ELIR submits a self-evaluation document called a Reflective Analysis (RA). The ELIR team uses this document and initial meetings with staff and students to develop themes for exploration during the review visits. These themes relate to six broad areas of institutional activity:
- Institutional context and strategic framework
- Enhancing the student learning experience
- Enhancement in learning and teaching
- Academic standards
- Self-evaluation and management of information
- Collaborative activity
At the end of the review, the ELIR team produces an Outcome report (covering the overarching judgment, the areas of positive practice and the areas for development) and a more detailed Technical report.
Handbook and supplementary guidance
Operational guidance for institutions:
Guidance for ELIR reviewers:
Guidance for students:
The purpose of these reports is to inform future development work in the Scottish higher education sector and future QAA activity. There are two main types of thematic reports: those identifying topics across a number of institutions' ELIR Outcome Reports, and those providing details on particular topics, drawing on the content of ELIR Technical Reports.
Learning from ELIR
The findings of ELIR reports are analysed in the Learning from ELIR series. The topics on which papers are available are:
Institutional approaches to self-evaluation (IASE) project
Scottish higher education institutions evaluate their learning and teaching in a variety of ways using procedures that have been developed over a number of decades. The Institutional approaches to self-evaluation (IASE) project, undertaken on behalf of QAA Scotland by Professor Paddy Maher during 2012-13, aimed to consider and codify the various arrangements that institutions have in place. The project considered four types of institutional evaluation: annual monitoring; institution-led quality review; preparation for ELIR; and transformational reviews of institutional processes.
Key reference points
Developing the ELIR 4 method
Individuals or groups are invited to submit an application to produce written guidance for Scottish higher education institutions on good practice in Reflective Analysis. It is expected that this project will help institutions consider ways to prepare the institutional self-evaluation document, Reflective Analysis, for the ELIR 4 method.